Revision 2

d15

 Revision 1 (edit)
By multi on 2018-02-08 at 15:17
Revision 2 (edit)
By yorhel on 2018-02-08 at 15:27
 Edit summary of revision 2:

Add conversion from the old HTML docs.
Content[empty]# Introduction

This page lists a few games that are commonly discussed for inclusion in the database and the reasoning for their inclusion or exclusion. Check [d2#1](/d2#1) for the general inclusion guidelines.


# Deleted Games

The following is a list of games that have been (proposed to be) included in the database, but that were removed or rejected. These games are **not** visual novels and will **not** be reinstated.

- **The Disgaea series (except for Infinite)**<br>
_They are TRPGs with no narration or uninterrupted VN segments._
- **Persona 3/4**<br>
_They are JRPGs and have no narration or VN segments._
- **Ghost Trick**<br>
_A Puzzle/Adventure game with no narration._
- **Princess Maker 1/2/3**<br>
_Pure raising sims with no narration or VN segments._
- **Battle Moon Wars**<br>
_Super Robot Wars style TRPG with no narration._
- **The Shin Megami Tensei series**<br>
_RPGs/TRPGs with no narration._
- **The Touho games**<br>
_Bullet hell shooters with only token character interactions._
- **Record of Agarest War / Agarest Senki**<br>
_No narration and very low story/gameplay ratio._
- **To The Moon**<br>
_An adventure game with no narration._


# Borderline Games

The following is a lists of few games that **are** included in the database, but are very much borderline cases. When arguing for another game to be included, do **not, ever,** refer to these games as examples.

- **The Ar Tonélico series**<br>
_The series is in the database because of the Cosmosphere sections, which are long, uninterrupted VN segments. The rest of the game might be a relatively typical JRPG, but it doesn't matter in this case._
- **The Phoenix Wright series**<br>
_The games are only considered VNs in the broadest sense, and thus they should not be cited as examples for inclusion. They are considered one of the few "mod approved" games that stay in the DB mostly because of reasons not necessarily related to the guidelines (in this case that removing them would cause more problems than keeping them)._
- **The Melty Blood series**<br>
_The only reason the series is in the DB is becasue the first game has narration and proper VN segments, and while the rest are straight up fighting games, they are only considered different releases of said game._
- **The BlazBlue series**<br>
_The game has narration in the ADV VN segments between battles and these segments are extensive enough to qualify it, if only barely._
- **The Rance series and other turn-based Alice Soft titles**<br>
_VN hybrids, Sengoku Rance in particular has a lot of narration, and while there is a lot of gameplay in them, they still qualify._
- **Castle Fantasia 2**<br>
_No consistent narration, but otherwise the game fulfills all other VN requirements, so it is kept as-is._
- **The Corpse Party series (except for the original and Rebuilded)**<br>
_The games have narration and event CGs, which qualify it over the lack of ADV/NVL presentation._
- **The School Days series (Shiny Days, Summer Days, etc.)**<br>
_While it would be arguable that the games are more "interactive anime" instead of VNs, they have rudimentary narration and other VN elements to qualify, albeit barely. They are the second most borderline "mod approved" keepers beside the Phoenix Wright series._
- **999 / Kyokugen Dasshutsu 9-Jikan 9-Nin 9 no Tobira / 9 Hours, 9 Persons, 9 Doors**<br>
_A pure VN with puzzles. I don't even know why people like to bring it up as an example, but it is a proper VN with narration and every other necessary aspect._
- **The Lightning Warrior Raidy series**<br>
_The games are mostly dungeon crawlers, but they have enough narrated ADV segments to warrant their presence in the DB, albeit barely._
- **Kamidori and other Eushully games**<br>
_These games have very extensive TRPG gameplay and crafting systems, but they also have equally extensive, uninterrupted and narrated VN segments throughout the games._

Special Games

1. Introduction

This page lists a few games that are commonly discussed for inclusion in the database and the reasoning for their inclusion or exclusion. Check d2#1 for the general inclusion guidelines.

2. Deleted Games

The following is a list of games that have been (proposed to be) included in the database, but that were removed or rejected. These games are not visual novels and will not be reinstated.

  • The Disgaea series (except for Infinite)
    They are TRPGs with no narration or uninterrupted VN segments.
  • Persona 3/4
    They are JRPGs and have no narration or VN segments.
  • Ghost Trick
    A Puzzle/Adventure game with no narration.
  • Princess Maker 1/2/3
    Pure raising sims with no narration or VN segments.
  • Battle Moon Wars
    Super Robot Wars style TRPG with no narration.
  • The Shin Megami Tensei series
    RPGs/TRPGs with no narration.
  • The Touho games
    Bullet hell shooters with only token character interactions.
  • Record of Agarest War / Agarest Senki
    No narration and very low story/gameplay ratio.
  • To The Moon
    An adventure game with no narration.

3. Borderline Games

The following is a lists of few games that are included in the database, but are very much borderline cases. When arguing for another game to be included, do not, ever, refer to these games as examples.

  • The Ar TonĂ©lico series
    The series is in the database because of the Cosmosphere sections, which are long, uninterrupted VN segments. The rest of the game might be a relatively typical JRPG, but it doesn't matter in this case.
  • The Phoenix Wright series
    The games are only considered VNs in the broadest sense, and thus they should not be cited as examples for inclusion. They are considered one of the few "mod approved" games that stay in the DB mostly because of reasons not necessarily related to the guidelines (in this case that removing them would cause more problems than keeping them).
  • The Melty Blood series
    The only reason the series is in the DB is becasue the first game has narration and proper VN segments, and while the rest are straight up fighting games, they are only considered different releases of said game.
  • The BlazBlue series
    The game has narration in the ADV VN segments between battles and these segments are extensive enough to qualify it, if only barely.
  • The Rance series and other turn-based Alice Soft titles
    VN hybrids, Sengoku Rance in particular has a lot of narration, and while there is a lot of gameplay in them, they still qualify.
  • Castle Fantasia 2
    No consistent narration, but otherwise the game fulfills all other VN requirements, so it is kept as-is.
  • The Corpse Party series (except for the original and Rebuilded)
    The games have narration and event CGs, which qualify it over the lack of ADV/NVL presentation.
  • The School Days series (Shiny Days, Summer Days, etc.)
    While it would be arguable that the games are more "interactive anime" instead of VNs, they have rudimentary narration and other VN elements to qualify, albeit barely. They are the second most borderline "mod approved" keepers beside the Phoenix Wright series.
  • 999 / Kyokugen Dasshutsu 9-Jikan 9-Nin 9 no Tobira / 9 Hours, 9 Persons, 9 Doors
    A pure VN with puzzles. I don't even know why people like to bring it up as an example, but it is a proper VN with narration and every other necessary aspect.
  • The Lightning Warrior Raidy series
    The games are mostly dungeon crawlers, but they have enough narrated ADV segments to warrant their presence in the DB, albeit barely.
  • Kamidori and other Eushully games
    These games have very extensive TRPG gameplay and crafting systems, but they also have equally extensive, uninterrupted and narrated VN segments throughout the games.